Home • PRRES Inc. Journal • Read the Journal

Variances in rateable values in rating practice in Zambia: the role of mental models in value assessment

Author/s: Ephraim K. Munshifwa, Niraj Jain, Busiku S. Kaunda, Lilias Masiba, Jimmy Lungu, Nelly Chunda-Mwango, Anthony Mushinge, Wilson Ngoma

Date Published: 3/05/2016

Published in: Volume 22 - 2016 Issue 2 (pages 181 - 201)

Abstract

Rating valuation is an essential process for local government taxation and revenue generation in Zambia. However, preliminary evidence indicates that the assessment of rateable value is problematic as the same statutory valuation process may lead to different value outcomes. This is especially evident when valuations are undertaken by public valuation surveyors on one side and private valuation surveyors on the other. This has resulted in disagreements in Rating Tribunal hearings at which private valuation surveyors represent the objectors. This paper questions why such differences arise. The paper finds that, besides information factors, a major cause is valuation surveyor-specific factors which, among others, include adoption of different methods and viewpoints. Therefore, the question arises: why do valuation surveyors have different viewpoints or “mental models” if the whole process is specified in the Rating Act of 1997? The study concludes that the Rating Act of 1997 is insufficiently specific concerning the actual calculation of the rateable value, leaving the interpretation of value to individual valuation surveyors. The paper argues that the explanation for differences in values can be found in understanding the “mental models” of valuation surveyors, hence going beyond conventional explanations.

Download Full Article

Download the Full Article PDF

14445921.2016.1225151.pdf 14445921.2016.1225151.pdf (1MB)

Keywords

Mental Models - Rateable Values - Rating Valuation - Value Assessment - Zambia

References

  • Addae-Dapaah, K. (2001) Valuation accuracy – a problematic enquiry, Paper presented at the eighth European real estate society conference. ,.
  • Adebayo, O. O.Osmond, I. C. (2010) A search for an acceptable margin of valuation error: A case study of valuation surveyors and their clients in Nigeria, Sri Lankan Journal of Estate. 4, p:54-73. Sri Lankan Journal of Estate.
  • Ajibola, M. O. (2010) Valuation inaccuracy: An examination of causes in Lago Metropolis, Journal of Sustainable Development. 3, –.p:187-193. Journal of Sustainable Development.
  • Ayedun, C. A.Oloyede, S. A.Durodola, O. D. (2012) Empirical study of the causes of valuation variance and inaccuracy in Nigeria, International Business Research. 5, p:71-80. International Business Research.
  • Baum, A.Crosby, B. (1995) Property investment appraisal. London: Routledge. Property investment appraisal.
  • Beale and Company. (2010) Valuation surveyors’ Negligence: The permissible “margin of error”. July. Retrieved June 21, 2015, [Online] from.Retrieved from www.beale-law.com/uploads/files/beale_and_company/publications/imported/2010.07.23—Valuers-negligence-margin-of-error.pdf
  • Boyd, T.Irons, J. (2002) Valuation variance and negligence, Pacific Rim Property Research Journal. 8, p:107-126. Pacific Rim Property Research Journal.
  • Bretten, J.Wyatt, P. (2001) Variance in commercial property valuations for lending purposes: An empirical study, Journal of Property Investment & Finance. 19, p:267-282. Journal of Property Investment & Finance.
  • Brown, G. R. (1985) Property investment and performance measurement: A reply, Journal of Valuation. 4, –.p:33-44. Journal of Valuation.
  • Brown, G. R. (1991) Property investment and the capital markets. London: & FN Spon. Property investment and the capital markets.
  • Brown, G. R.Matysiak, G. A.Shepherd, M. (1998) Valuation uncertainty and the Mallinson Report, Journal of Property Research. 15(1), p:1-13. Journal of Property Research.
  • Chang, K. H.Horrocks, S. (2008) Is there a place for ontological hermeneutics in mental-health nursing research? A review of a hermeneutic study, International Journal of Nursing Practice. 14, p:383-390. International Journal of Nursing Practice.
  • Chitakunye, P. (2009) Everyday practices surrounding young people’s food consumption: The mediating influence of the television on family dynamics.PhD thesis. Keele University. Everyday practices surrounding young people’s food consumption: The mediating influence of the television on family dynamics.
  • Chota, M. (2014) Assessing the application of project management techniques in valuation roll preparation – A case study of Ndola city council. KitweUnpublished MSc thesis. The Copperbelt University. Assessing the application of project management techniques in valuation roll preparation – A case study of Ndola city council.
  • Crosby, N.Lavers, A.Murdoch, J. (1998) Property valuation variation and the margin of error in the U.K, Journal of Property Research. 15, p:305-330. Journal of Property Research.
  • Denzeu, A. T.North, D. C. (1994) Shared mental models: Ideologies and institutions, Kyklos. 47, p:3-31. Kyklos.
  • Diaz, J.Wolverton, M. L. (1998) A longitudinal examination of the appraisal smoothing process, Real Estate Economics. 26, p:349-358. Real Estate Economics.
  • Evans, A. W. (1995) The property market: ninety per cent efficient?, Urban Studies. 32, –.p:5-30. Urban Studies.
  • French, N.Gabrielli, L. (2004) The uncertainty of valuation, Journal of Property Investment and Finance. 22, p:484-500. Journal of Property Investment and Finance.
  • GRZ. (1997) Rating act No. 12 of the laws of Zambia. Lusaka:Government Printers. Rating act No. 12 of the laws of Zambia.
  • GRZ. (1999) Rating (amendment) act No. 9 of the laws of Zambia. Lusaka:Government Printers. Rating (amendment) act No. 9 of the laws of Zambia.
  • Hager, D.Lord, D. (1985) The property market, property valuations and property performance measurement. London: Institute of Actuaries. The property market, property valuations and property performance measurement.
  • Harvard, T. (1996) Investigating the causes of valuation variance: The impact of personality type on valuation surveyor behavior. RICS Research Report. London:RICS. Investigating the causes of valuation variance: The impact of personality type on valuation surveyor behavior. RICS Research Report.
  • Hordijk, A. (2005) Valuation accuracy in real estate indices: The case of the ROZ/IPD Netherlands Property Index Compared to the IPD UK Index and the NCREIF USA, IVSC Information Paper. ,.
  • Hutchison, N.McGregor, B.Nanthakumaran, N.Adair, A.McGreal, S. (1996) Variations in the capital valuations of UK commercial property. RICS Research Report. London: RICS. Variations in the capital valuations of UK commercial property. RICS Research Report.
  • Johnson-Laird, P. N. (2001) Mental models and deduction, Trends in Cognitive Sciences. 5, –.p:434-442. Trends in Cognitive Sciences.
  • Jud, G. D.Frew, J. (1986) Real estate brokers, housing prices, and the demand for housing, Urban Studies. 23, p:21-31. Urban Studies.
  • Jumba, J. (2005) A critical analysis of the law and practice of rating in Zambia, Lusaka: Retrieved October 1, 2015, [Online] fromUnpublsihed LLB thesis. University of Zambia. Retrieved from http://dspace.unza.zm:8080/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/2579/Jumbo-J0001.PDF?sequence=1
  • Kabisa, M. (1994) The rating act: The 22 stages of preparing a valuation roll. Lusaka:Unpublished. Council Rating Workshop. The rating act: The 22 stages of preparing a valuation roll.
  • Kabuka, C. W. (2008) A critical analysis of the implication of Taxation stability under mining development agreements on levying of rates on mining property in Zambia. Lusaka. Retrieved October 1, 2015, [Online] fromUnpublished LLB thesis. University of Zambia. A critical analysis of the implication of Taxation stability under mining development agreements on levying of rates on mining property in Zambia. Retrieved from http://dspace.unza.zm:8080/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/2412/KabukaCW0001.PDF?sequence=1
  • Kummerow, M. (2003) Theory of real estate valuation: An alternative way to teach real estate price estimation methods, Australia: ,. Retrieved October 16, 2015, [Online] fromResearch Monograph, Department of Land Economy and Valuation, Curtin University. Retrieved from www.prres.net/papers/kummerow_theory_for_real_estate_valuation_an_alternative_way_to_teach_real_estate_price_estimation_methods.pdf
  • Mooya, M. M. (2009) Market value without a market: Perspectives from transaction cost theory, Urban Studies. 46, –.p:687-701. Urban Studies.
  • Mosimane, A. W. (2013) Collective identity and collective action in the management of common pool resources: a case study of Doro !Nawas Conservancy in Namibia.PhD thesis. University of KwaZulu-Natal. Collective identity and collective action in the management of common pool resources: a case study of Doro !Nawas Conservancy in Namibia.
  • North, D. C. (1990) Institutions, institutional change and economic performanceCambridge University Press. Institutions, institutional change and economic performance.
  • Ogunba, O. A. (1997) A study of valuation and pricing methods in the residential property market in Lagos metropolis. Ile-Ife.Unpublished MSc thesis. Obafemi Awolowo University. A study of valuation and pricing methods in the residential property market in Lagos metropolis.
  • Parker, D. R. R. (1998) Valuation accuracy – An Australian perspective, Paper presented at 4th pacific rim real estate conference held on 19–21th January. ,.
  • Ratcliff, R. U. (1972) Valuation for real estate decisions. Santa Cruz, CA:Democrat Press. Valuation for real estate decisions.
  • Richards, D. (2001) Coordination and shared mental models, American Journal of Political Science. 45, –.p:259-276. American Journal of Political Science.
  • Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors. (1992) Statements of asset valuation practice and guidance notes. London:Author. Statements of asset valuation practice and guidance notes.
  • Schuck, E. J.Levy, D. (1999) The Influence of clients on valuations: the client’s perspective, RICS cutting edge research conference.
  • Skitmore, M.Irons, J.Armitage, L. (2007) Valuation accuracy and variation: A meta analysis, Proceedings 13th pacific rim real estate society conference.
  • Squirell, M. (1985) Uncertainty in real estate decisions, The Appraiser. , –.p:375-386. January. The Appraiser.
  • Thagard, P. (2010) How Brains Make Mental Models, Model-based reasoning in science & technology. Berlin Heidelberg: In (Eds.), (pp. –)p:447-461. Springer-Verlag. Model-based reasoning in science & technology.
  • World Bank. (2015) World development report 2015 – Mind, society and behaviour. Washington, DC: Retrieved March 1, 2016, [Online] fromIBRD/The World Bank. World development report 2015 – Mind, society and behaviour. Retrieved from www.worldbank.org/content/dam/Worldbank/Publications/WDR/WDR%202015/Chapter-3.pdf
  • Wrenn, M. V. (2006) Agency and mental models in heterodox economics, Journal of Economic Issues. 40, –.p:483-491. Journal of Economic Issues.
  • Whipple, W. T. M. (1995) Property valuation and analysis. Sydney:Law Book. Property valuation and analysis.