Home • PRRES Inc. Journal • Read the Journal

Alternative assets – a new challenge to property? An analysis of superannuation funds

Author/s: Wejendra Reddy

Date Published: 3/05/2016

Published in: Volume 22 - 2016 Issue 2 (pages 127 - 143)

Abstract

Leading Australian superannuation funds now have major exposure of approximately 20% to a sector classified as alternative assets. Within this sector, there are infrastructure products, which have similar characteristics to property. Thus, an ongoing debate on whether alternatives can replicate the performance of property in mixed-asset portfolios. This research examines the diversification benefits of property, infrastructure, private equity, hedge funds and commodities within two-asset and multi-asset optimisation portfolios. It uses ex-post data (1995–2015), from A$431 billion industry superannuation funds balanced portfolio. The methodology also involves substituting smoothed with desmoothed property data to detect any subsequent change in property allocation levels. The results from the two-asset portfolios illustrate that including infrastructure, hedge funds and private equity in the direct property portfolio provides high risk-adjusted returns (.45–.51), although portfolio weight is dominated by direct property. Analysis on multi-asset portfolios clearly shows that substituting smoothed property with desmoothed property data is insignificant to both industry fund performance and its weighting to property. Despite similar asset allocation range assigned to property and infrastructure (0–20%), infrastructure allocation was 3%, lower than property (13%). Strong allocations to property highlight its significance in institutional portfolios, even with the availability of similar alternative assets. For industry superannuation funds, the empirical results show that allocation to property can be higher than current 10%, backed by improved portfolio risk-adjusted returns. The research contributes to both practical and academic fields as it offers a methodological approach on how allocation to property assets can be improved using a series of asset allocation strategies.

Download Full Article

Download the Full Article PDF

14445921.2016.1203722.pdf 14445921.2016.1203722.pdf (1MB)

Keywords

Alternative Assets - Asset Allocation - Australian Superannuation - Diversification Options - Infrastructure - Property

References

  • Ankrim, E. M.Hensel, C. R. (1993) Commodities in asset allocation: A real-asset alternative to real estate?, Financial Analysts Journal. 49, p:20-29. Financial Analysts Journal.
  • Anson, M. J.Fabozzi, F. J.Jones, F. J. (2011) The handbook of traditional and alternative investment vehicles: Investment characteristics and strategies, The Frank J. Fabozzi Series. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
  • Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA). (2015) Quarterly superannuation performance: September 2015. Sydney:Author. Quarterly superannuation performance: September 2015.
  • Austrade. (2010) Alternative investments in Australia. Canberra:Austrade Financial Services Division, Australian Trade Commission. Alternative investments in Australia.
  • AXA Real Estate. (2012) Property’s place in a mixed-asset portfolio. London:AXA Investment Management Company. Property’s place in a mixed-asset portfolio.
  • Baum, A.Hartzell, D. (2012) Global property investment: Strategies, structures, decisions. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell. Global property investment: Strategies, structures, decisions.
  • Bond, S. A.Hwang, S.Mitchell, P.Satchell, S. S. (2007a) Asset allocation in the modern world. London: Investment Property Forum. Asset allocation in the modern world.
  • Bond, S. A.Hwang, S.Mitchell, P.Satchell, S. S. (2007b) Will private equity and hedge funds replace real estate in mixed-asset portfolios? Not likely, The Journal of Portfolio Management. 8,, p:74-84. September ed. The Journal of Portfolio Management.
  • Bond, S. A.Hwang, S.Marcato, G. (2012) Commercial real estate returns: An anatomy of smoothing in asset and index returns, Real Estate Economics. 40, p:637-661. Real Estate Economics.
  • Brown, G. R.Schuck, E. J. (1996) Optimal portfolio allocations to real estate, The Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management. 2, p:63-73. The Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management.
  • Colonial First State Global Asset Management (CFS). (2009) Evaluating infrastructure from a property perspective: The case for a diversified real asset allocation. (November ed., CFS Research Series) Sydney:Author. Evaluating infrastructure from a property perspective: The case for a diversified real asset allocation.
  • Finkenzeller, K.Dechant, T.Schäfers, W. (2010) Infrastructure: A new dimension of real estate? An asset allocation analysis, Journal of Property Investment and Finance. 28, p:263-274. Journal of Property Investment and Finance.
  • Future Fund. (2016) Portfolio update at 31 December 2015. Melbourne:Author. Portfolio update at 31 December 2015.
  • Geltner, D. M. (1991) Smoothing in appraisal-based returns, The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics. 4, –.p:327-345. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics.
  • Geltner, D. M. (1993) Estimating market values from appraised values without assuming an efficient market, Journal of Real Estate Research. 8, –.p:325-345. Journal of Real Estate Research.
  • Geltner, D. M.Miller, N. G.Clayton, J.Eichholtz, P. (2007) Commercial real estate analysis & investments. (2nd ed. ed.). Mason, IA: Thomson South-Western. Commercial real estate analysis & investments.
  • Higgins, D. (2014) Australian commercial property investment market: Styles, performance and funding. Melbourne:Australian Centre for Financial Studies. Australian commercial property investment market: Styles, performance and funding.
  • Hoesli, M.Lekander, J.Witkiewicz, W. (2003) International evidence on real estate as a portfolio diversifier. Geneva: International Center for Financial Asset Management and Engineering. International evidence on real estate as a portfolio diversifier.
  • Jones Lang LaSalle. (2012) Real assets and the Asia Pacific. Sydney:Jones Lang LaSalle Global. Real assets and the Asia Pacific.
  • JP Morgan Asset Management. (2012) The realization: A new world – a new normal – a tectonic shift. New York, NY:JP Morgan Chase & Co. The realization: A new world – a new normal – a tectonic shift.
  • Lee, S.Byrne, P. (1995) Is there a place for property in the multi-asset portfolio?, Journal of Property Investment & Finance. 6, p:60-83. Journal of Property Investment & Finance.
  • Marcato, G.Key, T. (2007) Smoothing and implications for asset allocation choices, The Journal of Portfolio Management. 33, p:85-99. The Journal of Portfolio Management.
  • Markowitz, H. (1952) Portfolio selection, The Journal of Finance. 7, –.p:77-91. The Journal of Finance.
  • Newell, G.Chau, K. W.Wong, S. K. (2009) The significance and performance of infrastructure in China, Journal of Property Investment & Finance. 27, p:180-202. Journal of Property Investment & Finance.
  • Newell, G.Lee, C. L. (2011) The impact of alternative assets on the role of direct property in australian mixed-asset portfolios, Pacific Rim Property Research Journal. 17, p:531-559. Pacific Rim Property Research Journal.
  • Newell, G.Lee, C. L.Kupke, V. (2015) The opportunity of unlisted wholesale residential property funds in enhancing affordable housing supply. Melbourne: (2015) AHURI Final Report No. 249. Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited. The opportunity of unlisted wholesale residential property funds in enhancing affordable housing supply.
  • Newell, G.Peng, H. W. (2008a) Assessing the significance of motivating factors and risk factors in infrastructure funds management, Pacific Rim Property Research Journal. 14, p:399-411. Pacific Rim Property Research Journal.
  • Newell, G.Peng, H. W. (2008b) The role of US infrastructure in investment portfolios, Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management. 14, p:21-33. Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management.
  • Newell, G.Peng, H. W.De Francesco, A. (2011) The performance of unlisted infrastructure in investment portfolios, Journal of Property Research. 28, p:59-74. Journal of Property Research.
  • Parker, D. (2011) Global real estate investment trusts: People, process and management. West Sussex:Wiley-Blackwell Publication. Global real estate investment trusts: People, process and management.
  • Peng, H. W.Newell, G. (2007) The significance of infrastructure in Australian investment portfolios, Pacific Rim Property Research Journal. 13, p:423-450. Pacific Rim Property Research Journal.
  • Rainmaker Group. (2012) Australian superannuation industry asset class weights: June 1995–December 2011. Sydney: (Data set)Author. Australian superannuation industry asset class weights: June 1995–December 2011.
  • Ross, S. A.Zisler, R. C. (1991) Risk and return in real estate, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics. 4, p:175-190. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics.
  • Rowland, P. J. (2010) Australian property investments and financing. Sydney:Thomson Reuters (Professional Australia) Limited. Australian property investments and financing.
  • RREEF. (2005) Understanding infrastructureRREEF Real Estate Research America. Understanding infrastructure.
  • Skully, M. (2007) Alternative investments: definition, importance and risks, JASSA: The FINSIA Journal of Applied Finance. 3, –.p:35-39. JASSA: The FINSIA Journal of Applied Finance.
  • Smith, M. (2016) Harnessing the power of alternative beta in a modern portfolio, Financial Standard. 14, –.p:14-17. Financial Standard.
  • Stevenson, S. (2000) Constructing optimal portfolios and the effect on real estate’s allocation, Journal of Property Investment & Finance. 18, –.p:488-506. Journal of Property Investment & Finance.
  • Worzala, E. M.Bajtelsmit, V. L. (1997) Real estate asset allocation and the Decisionmaking framework used by pension fund managers, Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management. 3, p:47-56. Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management.